The November 6th election for OVSD school board candidates may not be the slam dunk the current list of hand picked candidates expect. Please register to vote. This must be done 30 days PRIOR to the November 6,2007 election.
Where to Apply to Register to Vote
- Apply to Register to Vote in Person
Individuals may apply to register to vote at a County Voter Registration Office or other designated sites. A link to County Contact Information is located to the left. - Apply to Register to Vote by Mail
An individual may apply to register to vote by mail in one of three ways. - The first option is to obtain a voter registration mail application form prescribed by the State or Federal government. The Secretary of the Commonwealth and all county registration commissions supply voter registration mail applications to all persons and organizations who request them, including candidates, political parties and political bodies and other Federal, State, and municipal offices.
- The second option is to download the voter registration application available from this site. It can be accessed through the Voter Registration link to the left.
- The third option is to complete the Online Pennsylvania Voter Registration Application Form which can also be accessed through the Voter Registration link to the left.
- Apply to Register to Vote at PennDOT
Individuals may apply to register to vote at a Department of Transportation photo license center when he/she obtains or updates his/her driver's license. - Apply to Register to Vote at Government Agencies
Individuals may apply to register to vote at many other State government offices, including: - State offices that provide public assistance and services to persons with disabilities.
- Department of Transportation photo license centers.
- Armed Forces Recruitment Centers
- Area Agencies on Aging.
- Centers for Independent Living.
- County Mental Health and Mental Retardation Offices.
- Student disability services offices of the State System of Higher Education.
- Offices of Special Education.
- ADA Complementary Paratransit offices.
Posts
216 comments:
1 – 200 of 216 Newer› Newest»Good job getting the word out to come and vote. The more people the better.
Also read the blogs down below.
Very interesting and sad.
The tax and spenders greed and selfishness may have pushed the community toooooo far.
Have I missed something? Five people are running for five positions in November and you are saying it's not a slam dunk? That is something I need explained to me.
We need an explanation, too....
Nothing is ever a slam dunk!!!
You still have time as well as anyone else to run if they choose to.
It would be a great day to see one of these 5 lose, or better yet all 5 lose.
Actually Mr. Heckman has out lived his welcome.
He needs to spend time with his family and grandchildren.
8:51 - you would
The silence from the OCC detractors is louder than the noise they usually make on the blog!
Wonder why?;
snore ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
What's up with the police giving tickets on every road, every few miles, all day long? I never saw so many people getting tickets. Is our crime rate so low that there's nothing left for the police to do but give out tickets?
were they actually giving tickets or were they doing one of those seat belt, Insurance card, registration and drivers license deals (which I guess is still giving tickets). I have heard a lot of 'click or ticket' commercials on the radio lately.
And what is with the uniforms that look like tee-shirts that say POLICE. Do they buy them at zerns?
It is hard to respect someoneone in a black tee-shirt. It is like trying to respect a teacher that isn't wearing a tie or dress.
I've seen other people dress weird at meetings before.
Does not matter how someone dresses, if they're doing a good job. If they're doing a lousy job, everything about them stands out.
Dear mama,
yes it does matter how certain individuals dress. If our community leaders dress like 'hobos', they are setting a bad example for others, regardless of how well the act in their respective leadership role.
If our children and grandchildren are influenced by their teachers, police officers, etc.. as they should be, and those groups of respective leaders lead by (bad) example, a future ripple affect will take place.
Last month I was summons for jury duty, and the instructions included a detail of acceptable and expected dress. Why? Based on the 'good job' theory, it shouldn't matter how I dress as long as I pay attention and fulfill my obligations to the best of my ability.
So I do feel that the police, and school teachers should dress in a manner that deserves respect, or they should not object to the lack of respect they receive from the public and/or children!
However 'mama', I do appreciate the fact that your comments were concise and not mean-spirited, I just respectfully disagree withopinion.
Actions speak louder than words and clothing.
Hey there mama,
Did you notice that some of the board members dress very nicely but fall short once they open their mouth?
Pappy
Did the board wear tuxedos or gowns when they passed all those tax increases?
Don't know what they wore, but I know what they should have been wearing. Running shoes and wind resistant clothing. And a good sun block to protect from all the hot air.
The front page article in the Sunday, Reading Eagle, “Legislators renew tax-reform push” discussed the various tax plans being considered in Harrisburg. The only true tax-reform package is the Plan for Pennsylvania’s Future.
It will eliminate school property tax in return for modest sales tax expansion and a slight increase in state income tax.
Perhaps, the feature equal interest is that is has SPENDING CONTROLS. All the other packages talk about finding ways to raise taxes, but not to curtail extravagant school board spending.
Please contact your Representatives and get them to support the Plan for Pennsylvania’s Future.
Our opportunity for change is now. Let's make sure the politicians hear our voice and not just the greed of the special interest groups.
You can click on the links of the home page of the blog to reach Representatives Kessler, Santoni and Senator O'Pake
OCC - I have already contacted the representatives in support of the commonwealth caucus (Plan for PA Future).
As far as I am concerned, raise the sales tax to 9%, broaden the base to include everything, including food, utilities and clothing, and then eliminate county property taxes, EIT at the local level and PIT taxes, as well as the rest of the crazy taxes that our state and local governments steal from us.
Honestly, I would support eliminating the county government out right!
JUST REMEMBER TO VOTE LOCALLY!
IT'S TIME TO LET THEM KNOW WE MEAN BUSINESS!
It's pathetic that our country has let voting turn into a "who cares" event. Hopefully, we can turn things around, before it's too late.
IT'S TIME TO LET THEM KNOW WE MEAN BUSINESS!
Who is them?
9:08 the current board, HELLO!!!
Obviously 9:08 has not voted and is not aware of why this blog was started in the first place.
...Obviously 9:08 has not voted and is not aware of why this blog was started in the first place...
6:35am - Your assumptions show your inability to think logically without jumping to a stupid and incorrect conclusions. I have not missed an opportunity to cast my vote in decades, even going through the administrative process to vote via the mail, when forced to travel.
I was just commenting/pointing out the lack of substance in a previous post. 'Vote Locally' as opposed to??? - All the candidates are local.
The majority of the existing board is not up for re-election, so you will be hard pressed to send a nasty message. At best you can get rid of two this cycle and deal with the other five in two years.
We all know that Heckman has been on the board for 20+ years (5 terms). How about the rest of them - Maloney and Hannum still in their first term.
How long have the other six been on the board, and what s/b the limit be 2-terms (eight years), or 3 - terms (12years).
Or is merely the public's responsibility to set the term limit via the voting booth, and vote out anyone beyond their useful life as an elected official.
No more than 2 terms. Richards has been on for more than 2 terms, McCarthy is on her 2nd or 3rd. term. Cappa is on his 2nd term if he is re-elected this fall. Heckman is on way toooo long and will be on his 6? term if he is re-elected. The 3 new people running are not guaranteed a spot on this board. Do not celebrate the victory before the vote.
The new 3 running have not had a public forum to tell the people in this district what they will do for the children and the citizens if they get elected.
They just assume they are already on the board. That is wrong.
...The new 3 running have not had a public forum to tell the people in this district what they will do for the children and the citizens if they get elected.
They just assume they are already on the board. That is wrong...
What the heck does that have to do with my inquiry? It sounds as if you are threatening me with not pursuing change, yet you appear to be dissatisified with the status quo.
I guess we should vote for the same old, same old. Maybe that is part of the Oley Historic crap!
As for the candidates organizing a forum????? Isn't that the job of civic organizations, such as the PTO, women's league of voters, republican national committee, etc. to invite prospective candidates to come try to earn a nomination to the ballot (during the primary season). Did any of the candidates, old or new say NO to any such events hosted by the OCC or any other organization.
Before I wrote this i re-read the entire blog and the previous blog looking for what suggestions to the school or the school's curriculum needs to be changed, and I did not find a single posting making a logical recomendation. I did not see where any of the bloggers talked about geometry, trigonometry or calculus. I did not see anyone post where changes to english class needs to be made, or the introduction into foreign language needs to be made.
All I read about was how the current board pee'd away $1.6 million for a track, which I agree to be a huge waste of $$$. If this blog is truly concerned with quality of education that our children/future are receiving, then post some concerns of substance, or re-elect the same two that have been on the board for the past 10 or 20 years, and thanks them for living up to the communities obligation.
If you want change, vote for change, and vote for concerned individuals.
It is ridiculous to say that 'new' board members are the same. But unfortuantely, so much of the stuff on this blog is ridiculous.
Vote for change is what has been written on this blog for years now!!! Do not vote for the 5 members that will be on the ballot. Write in a new person. There is an area on the voting machine to do such a thing. It is called a write in.
We know that the new 3 will not help the majority of the people and children of this district. They been coming to meetings not asking a single question.
They do not know what a board member is to do once they are on the board. How will they be able to vote on the next years budget when they have not ask any questions regarding how this district runs and what the requirements are for this district?
You ask about term limits, you got an answer on term limits and that is NO MORE THAN 2 TERMS LIKE THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES!!!!!
It is not ridiculous to say that the 3 new members will be the same or are the same as the current board members. Come and see the new 3 in action or lack of action at the next board meeting.
The new yes votes are coming!!!!
Here we go again and again.
DO NOT VOTE THEM IN. DO NOT VOTE ANY OF THEM IN. IF YOU HAVE NO OTHER PERSON TO VOTE FOR DO NOT VOTE AT ALL.
YOU DO NOT HAVE TO VOTE FOR THESE 5 JUST BECAUSE THEY MAY BE THE ONLY 5 RUNNING AND THERE ARE 5 OPEN SPOTS ON THE BOARD.
THERE ARE MANY OTHER GOOD DECENT PEOPLE THAT YOU CAN WRITE IN!!!!
THINK HARD BEFORE YOU PRESS THE VOTE BUTTON!!!!!!!
WE ARE STUCK WITH THEM ANOTHER 4 LONG YEARS!!!!
It is up to the new 3 members to have a meeting or forum on their ideas and concerns for this district. They are the ones that need the votes come Nov.
Also one new member trying to get on the board has his wife on the current board.
She and the rest of the group that ran 4 years ago had a meeting for the public at the middle school.
DON'T YOU REMEMBER!!! THAT WAS ONE OF THE MEETINGS WHEN A POLICE OFFICER WAS CALLED TO STAND IN THE BACK OF THE MIDDLE SCHOOL AUDITORIUM "JUST IN CASE"!!!
THE BIG CHIEF WAS THINKING TROUBLE WAS LERKING WITH THE CONCERN CITIZENS COMING TO ASK IMPORTANT QUESTIONS.
Who could forget the school board meetings with the LAW standing in the wings?
Eat donuts
guard the school board
give out tickets for going 5 miles above the limit
Oh, yeah, and read magazines in King's parking lot.
Another cushy deal.
If anyone wants to know where any of the new board members stand on any issue all they have to do is pick up the phone and call them.
Dear 8:27 a.m.
"I have not missed an opportunity to cast my vote in decades, even going through the administrative process to vote via the mail, when forced to travel."
"The majority of the existing board is not up for re-election, so you will be hard pressed to send a nasty message. At best you can get rid of two this cycle and deal with the other five in two years."
Since per your post you present yourself to be in the know on current local events, this is just an FYI:
Contrary to your post, there are five (5) positions open on the board for the November 6, 2007 ballot, 2 incumbents are running and 3 new people, and I believe this equals a majority of the board at last count.
So now you don't like the police either? Who do you miserable people like (besides yourself)?
A little testy arent' we, 8:54?
Hey 8:54, did you have a BAD day?
8:54pm:
One thing we "miserable people" do not like is seeing that the average SAT score in Oley fell 65 points from 2006. That's the largest drop of any school in the county. Is anything being done to correct this trend? Is anyone being held accountable? Of course not. We reelect the same like minded board members who in turn extend the contracts of the same old administrators and we expect change or improvement? Dream on.
Dear 8:36 - I said 'majority of the EXISTING board is not up for re-election.'
There are only 2 'EXISTING board members' up for re-election.
2 is not a majority.
As for the reading eagle article this morning. That is a concern that should be debated.
Why must questions be asked at board meetings to be considered engaged? If individuals research and pursue answers via other means, such as going to the business office, sub-committee meetings, etc., does that mean the are out of touch?
There are many people in the community that ask questions or voice concerns to the board and the administration without attending meetings.
hahahahahahha
This blog is outrageous! But it sure is good for a laugh! hahahahahahahahahahah
Okay 10:19:
"At best you can get rid of two this cycle and deal with the other five in two years."
In two years there will only be four positions open, not five.
Our board has 9 members. There are five positions open on our current board of 9. I was referring to the board positions that are up for election.
2 people are running for re-election and three have chosen not to. This equals 5 positions that have to be filled.
5 positions can be construed as a majority.
So what is it exactly that you are trying to say?
You can get rid of anyone you want. Fact is, NOTHING will change until you've got a different person acting as the President of the Board. Nothing!
7:33am:
Comments like that could only come from someone who is intellectually challenged. You have a hard time functioning in the arena of ideas, right?
hello 9:12
I just cruised by the "arena of ideas" department. I didn't notice any of yours on display.
What happened at the property meeting last night? Did they approve anything?
OCC -- make sure you educate everyone how to vote for write in candidates. A Write In program can upset the apple cart. It will be interesting to see what happens.
As for us, we just got our tax bill for county, local and school tuitions for the few children we have here that attend surrounding district schools -- at their choice.
Don't miss Oley's taxes one bit -- but do miss the good friends of the OCC. Congratulations with the affiliation with the statewide taxpayers groups. Keep up the good work!!! (:
Hi Linda, We miss you and are glad you are doing great!!!
Your friends from the OCC!!!
Thanks for the above blog!!
It is nice to know that you care for the people in the Valley even though you moved.
You are a true friend!!
PS: Pray for Danny Hoch who passed away this week!!
May he rest in peace forever!!
Another great and caring citizen of the Valley!!!
The truth and fiscal responsibility is all anyone ever wanted!!!!!
I read in the paper that a group wants a "football stadium" in Oley! Do these people care the burden their selfishness and greed puts on families struggling to pay property taxes??
Oley nepotism now extending into another district and county!
Zackon at all the home football games, cheer on Zackon!! Did you promise them a new football stadium with all the trimmings???
Why do you hire your family members all the time?
Do you have them as your eye spy's for the 3 school buildings??
I thought you did not like rumors and here say?
An honest response is warranted!!
There are good caring people that have tried to get a position in this district that you refuse to hire.
There are children in the Elemenatary School that are asking for this kind caring person.
Under Heckman and Cappas watch, our taxes have gone up 72% the last 6 years and we have nothing to show for it, in our test scores. The scores have either remained the same or gone down. This is outrageous. It is time for a change.
The other 3 canditates are trying to slip under the radar. They rarely if ever attend school board meetings.
This means they will have to be totally retrained as board directors.
We do not need trainees on the school board.
Our children are not guinea pigs.
Kubitz, Bieber, and Burns want to be on the board to vote for football. Cappa and Heckman want higher taxes. Some choices!
You are correct.
What ever happened to :) ?
He will show his face come November when he tries to scare the voters off.
Hope the pro-boarders leave any signs they might not like alone.
You know that is stealing!!!
...The other 3 canditates are trying to slip under the radar. They rarely if ever attend school board meetings.
Kubitz, Bieber, and Burns want to be on the board to vote for football. Cappa and Heckman want higher taxes. Some choices!...
Someone is not checking the facts, and not telling the truth. Based on the minutes posted on the school's web-site, these candidates have attended many/most of the meetings. And two of the three candidates previously attempted to get on the board in the previous elections, even before there was football. And this also goes to show that they are not hand-picked candidates.
Please check the facts before you blog, and stop misrepresenting the truth.
The above person is out of touch!!
Who said they are hand-picked???
Those words did not come up on this blog before!
They might have been seen at board meetings but they might as well stay home, they do not ask one question and sometimes they look like they rather be somewhere else.
Another 3 YES people we do not need on this board.
Why are they not asking questions and doing research on how a school board is supposed to be run???
How can they sit not asking and questions when a budget of over $20 million is being discussed!
No one can think they know how to manage that kind of money.
Our children will not be guinea pigs!!!
I hope they do not think they have gotten in already.
November will be telling.
"Another 3 YES people we do not need on this board."
Well they certainly don't need any "no" people either!
I don't think Cappa really wants higher taxes. But I'm pretty sure he likes the perks he gets by being married to a hefty recipient of benefits.
Why not 6:52? If the board actually knew what they are voting on half the time they would be saying "no" to it. Not every vote should have the whole board voting "yes". THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME!!! THEY SAY "YES" AND AFTER THEY VOTE "YES" THEY ASK QUESTIONS REGARDING WHAT THEY JUST VOTED ON!!! SICK, STUPID BUT TRUE!!
We need kind, caring, responsible adults who cares for the whole district not just a few special interests groups.
Have you noticed the sheriff sale signs up in front of houses driving around???
I have and it is a sad time when you see families getting forced out of their homes!
The board needs to be more fiscally responsible and honest and really know, I mean have full knowledge about what they are voting on.
We have wasted hundreds of thousands of dollars on lawsuits, non-educational items, high salaries and benefits, big retirement packages and than we see low test scores and children dropping out and the learning support children not getting the education they need to succeed in life.
We must do more for the children. They are the future of our country.
There are sheriff's sales everywhere...I'm sure the Oley Valley doesn't have an excess of them. You crazy Doomsdayers
8:36 your funny, NOT!!
One child not having a place to call home is to much.
We do not live in LALA land,everything is wonderful 24/7. Yes we are grateful for all that the Lord has given us.
But we all could approve in helping our neighbors and being nice and honest to each other.
Good Night :).
And no I am not the original :).
He has left this blog site but we will see and hear from him soon!!
Nice editorial in todays paper! It does not look good for this district when the taxpayers are this upset. He is justified in what he said.
Board Meeting: 10/10/07
The school board continues to shuffle funds to the determent of the taxpayers.
They approved transferring $1,500,000 of money from the General Fund to the Capital Reserve Fund. The ultimate effect of this transaction is to raise millage.
The $1,500,000 surplus is from the district miscalculating the 2006-2007 budget, $800,000 came from “unexpected” revenues, and $700,000 from unspent budget dollars.
The size of the misjudgment raises serious questions about the ability of the district and the board to manage our tax dollars.
This episode exceeds the $741,000 of missed revenue in a previous budget.
The board had the authority not to transfer the money into Capital Reserve and leave it in the General Fund for potential tax relief. But, true to form, the following board members gave a stiff arm to us, Robert A. Heckman, Ralph C. Richard, Mary Anne McCarthy,Barbara M. Bieber, Robert J. Cappa, Scarlette Z. Gotwals, Christopher M. Hannum, David M. Maloney, Sr.
This is the second major recent transaction of this type because the board ratified the placement of the $1,400,000 Nextel windfall in the Capital Reserve as well.
$2,900,000 of money kept away from property tax relief, coupled with a 72% millage increase over a few years, underscores the board’s total indifference to the hardships they impose on the community.
We do not exist in their minds until it is time to pay for their fiscal agenda.
It is time for a change.
News Flash
Senator Gibson Armstrong (R-York, Lancaster) circulated a co-sponsorship memorandum that would eliminate/modify 5 backend referendum exceptions.
The Pennsylvania School Board Association immediately sent an alert to their members to oppose any attempt to restrict their taxing authority and power grab.
Until a tax reform package is passed, it is a good idea to contact your legislatures and ask them to support Senator Gibson's memorandum.
Maybe they are saving for that football stadium.
I would like to hear from someone as to the reason for piling up all this money in the Capital Reserve Fund. And don't give me the excuse that "it's for an emergency". No emergency warrents that kind of capital build-up. A truthful answer would be nice. After all, it's OUR money, don't we deserve at least that?
I hear they are planning on spending a lot on a cooking lab. They will call the new 'kitchen' a teachers lounge.
I'm pretty sure it's for an emergency! Oops! ;)
By the way, what happened to :) ? I kind of miss him.
"...The above person is out of touch!!..."
Another senseless and childlike comment!
"...Who said they are hand-picked???
Those words did not come up on this blog before!..."
The front page of this blog terms them as hand-picked. I suspect you do not actually read the what is written before you start ranting and raving, without logic.
Who cares if the word hand-picked was used before or not. Tell me Mr.- know-it-all who has been on this board in the past that this board did not want on????
It has been along time since really good caring folks that wanted fiscal responsibility and had concerns for all the people sat on this board.
NOW IS THE TIME FOR A REAL GOOD HONEST PERSON TO GET ON THIS BOARD.
YES IN THE PAST A MAN "DB" WENT RUNNING TO THE COURTHOUSE TO STOP ANY GOOD CARING PERSON TO RUN FOR THIS BOARD.
YES IN THE PAST THE BOARD MEMBERS WERE CHOSEN. I WOULD SAY SCARE TACTICS HAVE PREVENTED ANY GOOD HARD WORKING PERSON TO RUN.
BUT NOT ANYMORE. WE ARE NOT SCARED. WE WANT THE TRUTH AND WE DESERVE TO GET IT. THIS IS OUR SCHOOL AND OUR CHILDREN'S EDUCATION WE ARE TALKING ABOUT.
IF THE CURRENT BOARD HAD A PROBLEM WITH THE 3 NEW PEOPLE RUNNING, YOU KNOW WELL ENOUGH THAT THE TROOPS WOULD BE OUT ATTACKING THEIR GOOD CHARACTER. BUT OF COURSE THEY ARE NOT WORRIED ABOUT THEM, AS THEY WILL VOTE RIGHT ALONG WITH THEM IF THEY GET ELECTED.
IT HAS HAPPEN BEFORE, IT CAN HAPPEN AGAIN.
Why not talk about all the large sums of money being put into the capitol reserved fund??
Why don't you write about the issues and not worry about the word "hand-picked"?
You cannot come to writing the truth. It would kill you to come out and actually care about what is really going on in this district.
I merely was pointing out inaccuracies that someone was trying to discredit another individual, and in return was verbally attacked. I can't help it if others wish to lie, via making accusations, but I do not like it and merely pointed the fact out.
As for commenting on the latest board blunder, I whole heartedly agree that the board was wrong for their movement of money. I believe it should have been left in the general fund to offset any possible tax increases for next year. It bothers me even more that the reserves are so large that they can be used by the union to justify large contracts in the future.
PS: I can voice my opinion without using capital letters for emphasis.
2:08 I am glad you agree with how the board is handling our money!
Have a nice weekend.
"YES IN THE PAST BOARD MEMBERS WERE CHOSEN."
Chosen by who? Who "chose" Linda B. or Barbara Frey, or Russ Hottenstein? I think you weaken your argument when you make such generalities. Anyway, what's past is done and if you want to be constructive start planning for changing the present board and future boards.
My second paragraph says that there used to be good, honest, caring board members in the past. But the majority of people that have gotten on this board, did not change anything or make this board worried that they might vote "NO". I am not talking about you, Linda, Barbara and Russ.
You are all the second paragraph.
Yes, I am one of the 3 new candidates running for School Director. I am dissapointed by some of the comments made, especially the ones directed at me, and the other new candidates. These statements are simply not accurate.
I was also dissapointed on how the board recently handled the transfer of money to the Capital Reserve Fund. This ultimatly will have a negative affect on taxpayers. Even though I do not agree on how it was handled, I do understand why it was done.
For those of you that want to know more about me, please contact me and ask. I will be as honest and open as possible...
More about me...
I am currently on the Board of Directors of two other entites. CAFA (The North American Coated Abrasive Fabricators Association), and Keystone Abrasives, of which I am also part owner and President. I consider myself to be a conservative Republican. I will promote fical responsibility, and educational excellence. Yes, I am pro athletics, including football, because I believe that they promotes character, and they are meaningful educational experiences for all that particapate. If you give a child a ball, some instruction and encouragement, it will result in a life experience they will never forget.
As some of you know, I ran for School Director 4 years ago, and lost by only a few votes. I ran again because I believe that I can make a difference and have a positive influence on decisions that influence both the students and taxpayers of the Oley Valley.
Yes, I know that I have more to learn, but I have already learned quite a bit, and I believe that I will be an effective School Director.
The comment about my silence is true, and on purpose. I know that to get anything accomplished you need five votes! Alienating yourself before even sitting on the board, would not be productive. After all it is a board decision, and not one opinion that results in action.
Verbally attacking board members, and administrators, is not a productive way to promote your position. Open discussion, reasonable understanding, and persistence, are all better approaches to achieving personal objectives.
I would be happy to meet with any concerned citizen to discuss issues concerning the Oley Valley School District. In fact I consider myself to be a concerned citizen.
SSB
Thanks for your comments and biography. Good luck on the board, too. You are in for an experience unlike any that you have had serving on any other board or committee.
I am glad to hear you were not in favor of the transfer of funds to the Capital Reserve though you write that you understand why they did it. I asked this question before and received no answers: Why did they do it? Could you share your understanding with us? It seems like an unnecessary move unless they are planning some blockbuster expenditure. Does it have anythingthing to do with a football porgram? The board and administration always complain about "rumors" out in the community but if they were open and forthright on issues such as this they could prevent alot of that.
Again, do your best and always try to balance the educational needs with the needs of the taxpayer. Don't be afraid to be the lone "no" vote on any issue and never sell your soul to the PSBA.
Dear RS:
Why assume that SSB is already elected?
Because write in campaigns fail 90% of the time!
11:03am:
I think I can go out on a limb and predict that he will be elected. A write-in candidate can only eliminate one opponent and I don't think it will be SSB.
You can't be serious.....you talk about it being a circus now!
Unlike the other new school board candidates, it is nice to see one finally, publicly express a view on an issue.
Perhaps, in the near future, the others would inform us of their platform.
I am a firm believer of the idea, that you measure a politician not by what they say but by what they do.
Cynthia E. Smith is for fiscal and educational accountability. She speaks frequently on behalf of the taxpayer at school board meetings, and most recently, at the House Finance meeting on property tax reform.
She not only attends the two school board meetings each month, but the committee meetings, as well.
She also does extensive, independent research on educational issues. She cares enough to do the work necessary to be a great school board member without being spoon fed by the administration. There would be no learning curve if she was elected.
The new candidates are not within missile distance of her knowledge and public commitment to fiscal and educational accountability.
Contrary to the new candidates belief, attending a few school board meetings before an election and remaining silent during those meetings does not qualify anyone for board director.
There is not a tax increase Heckman and Cappa have not approved. Our taxes reflect the fondness these two have for extravagance.
It is time for change.
We need a fresh new perspective on the board not "rubber stampers" for the status quo.
Cynthia E. Smith, is the only taxpayer candidate.
I was informed that readers of this blog were interested in hearing from the individuals running for the school board. I am also a candidate running for school board. I ran unsuccessfully for the position two years ago. I have two children who are currently enrolled in the school, and believe that I can provide a positive impact and provide fresh ideas concerning the operations of the school. I am fiscally conservative/responsible, and do not believe that anyone should be unnecessarily taxed.
I am not against having a small amount of money available for a rainy day, but believe that if large amounts of money, such as the $1.5 million, gets shifted into a capital reserve fund, then it should be earmarked for a known identifiable purpose.
Activities and sports: I believe that if a child is doing well academically, that keeping that child involved in activities such as band or athletics will further assist that child in growing into a productive member of our community. I volunteer as a coach for several activities, such as: Girls Softball, Boys Baseball, Football and Elementary Wrestling, and also coached soccer.
School board meetings: I do frequently attended school board meetings. For the last several months, I have been quiet, because I wish to observe and learn about the board. If elected to this position, I will need to work with the other eight board members. Creating adversaries prior to being elected will not help create an open environment and provide opportunity for change.
The primary reason that I have chosen to run for the school board (again) is my concerns regarding the current curriculum. I do not believe that our curriculum is keeping pace with what our children will need to succeed.
Personal background: I have a bachelor’s degree in business administration/Accounting. I am a certified public accountant. I am currently pursuing a Master’s degree in Business Administration (Saturday classes). I have had the privilege of serving on the Pike Township’s planning commission. I also had the opportunity, last year, to sit on the School Board’s Tax Commission Study (TSC) regarding the Act 1 referendum question, which the school board opted for something other than what the TSC’s recommended (?).
Therefore, I consider myself a concerned parent, a concerned citizen, and a concerned taxpayer.
cjk
I am so glad someone will be running for this board that really cares about all the children and citizens of this district.
She takes hours of her own time doing educational research, asking questions at board meetings for you, yes you and your children, yes your children!
I would think twice about attacking such a caring person. There has not been one person in the past 4 years on this board that represents the community as a whole.
They get on the board not knowing how this district should be run, they do not care to ask important questions and then they vote yes on everything and then ask questions after it is to late to change their vote.
I know of one person on this board that was upset after she voted for Zackon's big raise. And after I asked her why she voted yes and she said she was scared to answer the newspaper reporters if they came over to her and asked her why she voted NO.
Yes, Oh yes a true story. Mrs. Smith is not afraid of voting for what is right for all of us in this district even if it means answering to the reporters.
SHE TRULY CARES FOR THIS DISTRICT AND HER CHILDREN AND YOUR CHILDREN.
Even if she does not get elected she will not go away from speaking and asking questions. Fiscal responsibility, honesty and education is what we always wanted.
This board does not like anyone asking questions regarding what they are doing to this district and our money.
The 3 new members running do not know what is going on in this district regarding our money, education and being honest.
They will be taken for a ride like the last bunch that got on this board.
Good Luck Mrs. Smith and you got my vote. Finally someone for ALL of us!!!
If these three are afraid to ask questions now, how will they feel when the pressure is on?
What happened to the slam dunk all of a sudden?
I thought the blog was dead.
THEY SPEAK!!! 3 years and 11 months and now they want to tell us who they are. WHY NOW???
Silence is golden - NOT!!
CJK:
What took you so long to let people know of your platform?
I believe the question was asked back on October 2nd, and a few times before.
It is important that those who write in Cindy's name DO NOT vote for any other candidates. It is the only way she will have a chance to win.
That philosophy will also ensure that cappa and heckman are re-elected. Those two are the best known individuals running, and if the previous blogs (earlier in the year) were accurate, got the highest vote count. If CS would win, her 'power' would be happered significantly if her victory aids the re-installment of the incumbents.
Well do not vote for them at all!! If they get 0 votes they do not win. If the other new 3 running get more then Heckman and Cappa and if Cindy gets more than all of them she and the 3 new ones will get in and only 1 old one will get back in.
Heckman should do the right thing once and for all and step down. He has been on this board way,way to long.
Cappa should do the right thing and step down. He has done nothing but cause trouble for this board. His wife's retirement package is with this school district and this is a conflict having him on the board voting on his and his wife's benefits.
Term limits is a must. The board would have to pick a new person if we did not have enough people to fill in the empty seats on this board.
An empty seat is better than Heckman and Cappa getting back on this board.
If you want to keep your house and sanity do not vote for these 2 individuals.
9:20 is right. However, if you think your way is better then by all means split your vote. There is no way you are going to vote out both Heckman and Cappa so the "bullet" vote, in my opinion, is the only way to go: write in C.S. and ignore the rest.
RS: I agree with the posting before you. I was told that CS is not the only write-in candidate, but that members of the current 'adminstration' do not even want at least 1 or 2 of the 'other' candidates, and are trying to sneak someone else in.
It is a shame that we must stoop as low as 'write-ins'.
12:08 and if that is true with what you are being told, does it really surprise you that this board would be up to its dirty tricks again??
Cindy Smith is the only true caring person for my vote.
I do not care what anyone says about her you cannot say she does not give 100% for this district, children and community.She is the only true candidate running. She is for all the people in this district not just the special interests groups.
She gets my vote for sure!
What is cindi's qualification and platform. In otherwords, what does she plan to change and accomplish. Several of you have chimed in stating how she is kind, wonderful, caring, loving, etc. What are her 'objectives'. They should be very specific, or she is no different than heckman, cappa and the boys.
Besides attending meetings, and apparently asking questions, what changes is she planning to propose and pursue. Is she qualified to manage the $20+ million dollar business. If so, Why? What sub-committee does she plan to chair. Isn't each board member given at least one, if not two. This should be answered by Cindi, not her fan club.
12:46 fan club? Why not ask the rest of the new people that are trying to be elected all the same questions you want Cindy to answer?
And do not worry she will let you know how she stands on issues etc.
She does not have a fan club, just some good honest people that know she will be the best for this district.
We have told you in the past of all her research of this district and state laws and asking important questions has had this board thinking twice on voting for something that was not in the best interest for this district.
She has had many years experience going to board meetings, requesting information from the administration and asking questions. Yes she has been caring for your child and mine and all the citizens in this district.
Like it or not.
You will be hearing from her soon.
Don't cry me a river! We are way past the time in this district and now we finally have someone like Cindy Smith that will help
with fiscal responsibility, better education and honesty. This current board has been lacking all of the above for years.
IT IS TIME FOR REAL CHANGE!
Dear 12:53: I will not vote for CS, because she didn't offer herself as a candidate 6 months ago. However, I will vote for you, because your postings crack me up! I am guessing your second initial is the same as Cindi's!
;)
1:20 wrong. My second initial is not S.
The truth cracks you up? I feel sorry for you.
Go see someone will you.
Cindy will research the $20+ million budget before she votes on it, not like the current board members. Barb Bieber cannot manage a $20+ million budget either can her husband, Kubitz or Burns. Heckman and Cappa cannot either. You cannot vote of a budget this big without knowing 100% what you are voting for. This board has voted for yes on these big budgets for years without any knowledge. Monies have been put into different funds for it looks as if the board needs to raise our taxes when the money is there all along.
This will not happen if Cindy is on the board.
And if she is not elected, she will not run and hide like Burns and Kubitz did when they did not get elected. She will continue to go to board meetings and ask questions and ask for honesty and fiscal accountability and an education her children and your children have a right in getting under the LAW of this great country. Good Day! :)
Have they put :) on a mission to find someone to become a write-in for their interests. Wow what a blow to the 3 new men who want to get elected to hear the board is trying to get other people into running as write-ins. Does it make you feel good knowing what is being done behind the closed doors?
November is sure to be interesting! For such a small district we sure do have alot of action going on. Never dull!!
Five reasons to keep an eye on Cindy:
1. Cindy is not afraid to ask questions.
2. Cindy seems to be able to attend more meetings than some of the current board members
3. Cindy has first hand experience with budgeting money
4. Cindy expects answers to all questions.
5. Cindy has spent countless hours researching the spending habits of the current board. If the board hasn't noticed this, they should have.
" I was told that CS is not the only write-in candidate, but that members of the current 'adminstration' do not even want at least 1 or 2 of the 'other' candidates, and are trying to sneak someone else in."
Naaaa...would someone give up a royal straight flush for five new cards?
The superintendent has just the hand he wants, rubber stamping, tax and spending sheep.
...royal straight flush...???
Royal...no
Straight...probably
Flush....y e s.....
It would be an outrage if a person wins an election, knowing he is moving out of the district so that the board can appoint a "team player".
Who is moving out of the district? Anyone in particular? If so, we should be made aware of it.
It would be wonderful if Cindy were to be elected to the school board. Wonderful, wonderful!!!!! I can only hope! But I will tell you that I am not thinking along the same lines as the fan club (AKA Cindy)
Well if the administration is planning on doing what you are saying, what like-minded person are they thinking to get to replace say Heckman or Cappa?? Having one or two of them off this board would be wonderful, wonderful!
Having someone like Cindy to run with her would be wonderful, wonderful! Time has finally come for a complete overhaul of this board.
"term player", I beg to differ. The word should be a "YES" person. Someone that does not do any research and does not care of the costs of their "YES" votes will have on the citizens and children of this district.
team not term
Cindy ...times 9 ... would be a real good change.
"It would be an outrage if a person wins an election, knowing he is moving out of the district so that the board can appoint a "team player"."
Isn't this against the law?
'...Cindy ...times 9 ... would be a real good change...'
If that were to happen we would never have to worry about expenses regarding new construction. They can put up a "big-top" tent in less than a day.
Instead of the 'gossip', why doesn't someone cite the name, and get to the 'facts'. I am sure that the issue could be resolved by a simple phone call.
Names? Facts? That would be too easy and verifiable. They would rather deal in intrigue. If it's true what's the harm in naming names?
Rumor has it that it is a female that is moving.
A female is not re-running for school board. It is only Cappa and Heckman. I thought that the person is running for board even though they are moving? Please respond with a name and stop playing games!!
It would not be a surprise if the administration is up to doing something like this. Anything in this district can happen! Like I said before, never dull around here!
"Instead of the 'gossip', why doesn't someone cite the name, and get to the 'facts'. I am sure that the issue could be resolved by a simple phone call."
Better yet, why don't the good ole boy(s) respond here?
All it takes to get the board interested in this blog, is to print something about a write in vote!
I heard the "football people" have a write-in candidate.
Heard the same thing last nite about the football guys. Probably one of the two boys that are always featured in the newspaper.
we'll see
Board Meeting: 10/17/07
The board approved the transfer of a teacher to the position of a technology coach. His salary will increase to $70,000 a year.
This is part of a grant program called the Classrooms of the Future.
The grant, and shared costs with another district will pay for the position. However, a substitute will be hired to cover his teaching position.
Cynthia E. Smith informed the board that as part of the experiment the district will need to find a “reliable local source” of revenue to supply laptops to all the students in the district.
They said they were not aware of this requirement. This information is available on the Internet.
This plan needs a lot more research. At this point only Mrs. Smith has done the homework on the subject.
Mrs. Smith has my vote and if a football person wants to run for school board he needs to do the same research as Mrs. Smith does all the time. Football is not education. Football is a sport. The last time I heard the name of our school is was the Oley Valley SCHOOL District. And tell me what does the word SCHOOL mean anymore?
I love the game of football but I feel with the amount of children in our district we should focus on the current sports like soccer, cross country, track and field, etc. These programs are goind to suffer if football comes into this district, we only have so many kids to go around.
How is football supposed to be paid for?
Is there money in a seperate fund for football?
We need to concentrate on the basic needs of our children.
Years ago the students did very well on state tests and they did not have computers, fancy buildings, every sport available, etc.
We need to educate our children. That should be our #1 priority.
Mrs. Smith has my vote too! heehee I will pay money to see her on the school board! hahahha
Classrooms for the future is not for the entire district...the state website specifically says it is for high schools only
Why would anyone think that is funny? Look at the clowns on there now. Talk about funny!
...because I have seen Cindy in action! Hooo Boy!! hahahaha
It's better to ask questions than to be led by the nose into the mire.
Why does everyone see Cindy Smith as a threat to the board?
She would only be one vote, and probably outvoted on every issue, so why all the hoopla because she is running for school board?
...She would only be one vote, and probably outvoted on every issue, so why all the hoopla because she is running for school board?
Because she did not commit herself to the position for the primaries. She did not open herself up to the general public.
Yes she has established herself on this blog, but this blog only represents a tiny percentage of the valley's community.
If the current board (members - not the board itself) supports a mystery write-in candidate, it would be viewed as a some devious act, and a power grab, etc.
However, it seems that such a sneak in for Cindy is acceptable.
I personally believe Cindy will make a fine board member, and I do not think that she will be the only NO vote in the future on many items. I just don't agree with back door politics, which is what this type of write-in campaign is. A write-in candidate is acceptable if they announce they are running, or they were unsuccessful at the primary and are still passionate about their desires to serve. But not honorable, or in the best interest in the community, if they run an underground campaign.
underground campaign???
Are you for real???
Don't you see her signs up everywhere?
I have seen them and people are getting them hand delivered to their homes.
The board and administration are the ones that do underground,sneaky politics!!!
Cindy has been very active in this district and is concerned for all of you. You should be thanking her for running not commenting in such a negative manner.
Did not open herself up to the general public? And can you tell me which 5 members running have talked to the public had a public forum, told the public what they will do once they if elected get on this board?
Can you think of something better to say, your comments are not true.
Go Cindy Go. You are the only one for the taxpayers.
You want to run to work for all the taxpayers not just a few special interest groups.
Cindy is not sneaking in as a write-in. Cindy running has been out in the public for a while. Even all the teachers/administration new back in September. Ask some of them.
Maybe you do not pay attention to what is going on in this district and who is actually running. Do your homework before commenting.
Typical response. A respectful comment met with attacks and put downs. The public is treated by the board at board meetings with more diplomacy and respect than those who wish object or share a different opinion.
And yes Cindy is attempting to sneak in. I hope that the football people and the board are also trying to sneak people in via write-ins.
Why all the hub bub! We have had write-in campaigns in the past.
If you consider Cindy so insignificant, what is the problem with her running? And yes the above blog is correct, we have had write-ins in the past. Cindy has presented herself as a write-in before Nov. I do not see anyone else coming forward with their name for a write-in.
Tell us who else wants to be a write-in!
10:20 who are you related to?
Your blog was not respectable.
"The public is treated by the board at board meetings with more diplomacy and respect than those who wish object or share a different opinion."
Thanks Rob, but we know better.
"The public is treated by the board at board meetings with more diplomacy and respect than those who wish object or share a different opinion."
Ha, Ha , Ho, Ho, Ho...the board shows their "respect" by passing a law to prevent the public from speaking at meetings.
GO FOOTBALL GO!
GO CINDY GO!
GO FOOTBALL GO!
GO CINDY GO!
Both have the the kids best interest at hand. CS has done her research and knows that student athletes excel in academics and have the highest success rate in college over any other subgroup of the student body.
GO FOOTBALL GO - GO CINDY GO!
I, for one, do consider her "running" (if you want to call it that) insignificant.
Dear 7:53:
Apparently Dr. Zackon did not think that Cindy Smith running for the board was insignificant, as he brought it up at the last teacher inservice day.
Wonder why?
Barb B. was going to change the world, too. She did nothing. We wish Cindy the best of luck. Cindy has many great things to offer our community, but the most notable is the fact that she's got drive that does not fade away.
Good luck, Cindy, the folks up the hill are cheering for you!
Wesley Snyder for school board!
He is just great with money, other people's money, NOT!
He has hurt alot of people, the school board hurts alot of people with tax increases that are not needed!!
todays paper, more and more poor and middle class families are making hard choices how to use their money, for food or medicine, go to the doctors or not, etc. This is showing that alot of people even in this area are having a hard time going paycheck to paycheck. The paycheck is not lasting to the next paycheck.
Go for it, Cindy! Nothing could be better for you than to actually SERVE on the board! I'm sure you'll learn a great deal about the reality of the educational system.
"I'm sure you'll learn a great deal about the reality of the educational system."
We already know what the "reality" is, money and benefits, benefits and money....
If anyone needs criticism, it's the citizens that don't go to any meetings at all. Don't pick on Cindy for attendting, paying attention, and asking questions. Ask yourself a question instead. Why does Cindy find time to go, and those who find fault with her don't attend. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black!
Thats right!
Wesley's got my vote. He is kind and caring. I am going to put flyers out this week that say "Vote for Wesley".
I love the sign that Cindy put up! It is great and everyone can see it. That was a great idea.
My vote goes to Cindy!
Signs never got anyone elected. It will take more than that.
12:05 of course signs do not elect someone, but they can help. And for your information Cindy knows what she will do if elected. She will help all the citizens and children of this district. She will be the taxpayers and childrens board member. Finally!!
Saw the signs on 73 and on by-pass, great locations. The community is talking.
Now, now do not be tempted to steal Cindy's signs. We are watching and it is against the law. Good night and sweet dreams!
Wesley! Wesley! Wesley! I agree. He is kind and caring. He would be great on our school board. And he has lots of experience with money too.
9:26, you are funny, NOT!
Go Wesley Go!
I am putting up his sign today. Wesley got my vote!
We need business people running our school board. Therefore, Wesley has my vote!
MONKEY BUSINESS, THAT IS ALL HE HAS BEEN DOING, SOUNDS LIKE OUR CURRENT BOARD. WE DO NOT NEED SOMEONE LIKE WESLEY ON OUR BOARD. HE IS IN ENOUGH TROUBLE.
Heckman is a business person and he runs the school board so I'm sure you will proudly vote for him.
He's done such a good job (hahahahah).
11:13am - I am with you. We need businessman running our board. Wesley gets my vote, as well as the accounting guy (Kubitz) and the small business manager (Burns). What business experience, or experience do the other four candidates have? That is where my vote lies!
11:54 Kubitz, Burns and Bieber, do not know one thing about how a school board runs. They have gone to a FEW meetings and they did not ask any questions, did not request any information, nothing! Business or no Business experience if you do not know what is going on in this district and what the board is doing, forget it.
Cindy knows what is going on, she asks questions, she requests information, she does research work outside of the board room. She has ask important questions that this board refused to answer. She would then find the answer by doing research on her own time.
My vote goes to Cindy and only Cindy.
Heckman and Cappa think they know how to run a school district, but their voting record speaks for itself. Time for them to go. NOW!
Go Cindy, Go! I would looooove to watch you actually have to run the school, instead of just criticize!! hehehehe You have my vote!!!! ;)
Criticize, you would say that!! Same ole, same ole!
Cindy's truth on this school district is your word "criticize". why are you scared of the truth? Oh please get a hold of yourself. Cindy went to this school district and cares deeply about it and all the children and citizens, something you cannot deal with.
Go call her and actually talked to her about what is really going on in this district or do you not want to hear the truth? The truth is not always pleasant but if you have children in this district you better wake up. Yes not all things are doom and gloom, but what this school board is doing with our money and lawsuits is enough to make you sick. Honesty is not a word in this boards minds.
New sniffing dog in Oley. When is it coming to visit our schools?
Let it rain, Let it rain, Let it Rain!
What a beautiful site, too see the rain. The creeks look low, and the grass looks brown.
Let it Rain!
(I know this has nothing to do with the school, I am just excited to see the rain, to see the plants get their needed watering.
Have a great day to all!
You must not be from Oley, 7:40am, you sound way too happy this morning. Don't you know that if you live in Oley you have to go around with a frown on yoiur face and a chip on your shoulder? :(
I am happy, and I am from Oley. I know it is not a normal trait, but what can I say.
I do have a serious question. Is there any news on the child who was diagnosed with this MRSA infection. I keep hearing about this cropping up all over the place, and see that Oley announced someone yesterday, via a posting on the schools web site.
As parents, what do need to do, if anything. Will the school need to be disinfected, like the other schools did, as shown on the news?
The web site says it was a high school student. However, all three schools share things like buses. Is this a cause for concern?
The web site says that if you have any questions you should call the school nurse and it gives her phone number and extension. I guess it would be as good a place to start as any in order to get your concerns addressed. Let us know how you make out...
"As parents, what do need to do, if anything. Will the school need to be disinfected, like the other schools did, as shown on the news?"
Zackon writes on the OVSD website, he wants parents to contact someone else not him about this serious problem. This is called passing the buck. Did this infection come from the new synthetic field?
"Did this infection come from the new synthetic field?"
Mayo Clinic: Risk Factors MRSA
Participating in contact sports.
CA-MRSA has crept into both amateur and professional sports teams. The bacteria spread easily through cuts and abrasions and skin-to-skin contact.
MRSA has been around for years. The media is currently blowing it way out of proportion. No need to panic. Check out the CDC website for more information.
Don't forget the Budget and Finance Committee Meeting tonight at 7:00 p.m. in the board room.
The auditor will be there to discuss our school audit, and perhaps we will get an explanation as to why this school district always seems to come up with the extraordinary amounts of money, conveniently after they have already passed the budget for the new fiscal year.
This district has big plans for additions to our high school and it is in every taxpayer's best interest to attend these budget meetings.
They're always crying poor, they then raise our taxes, and then find the mysterious money they didn't know they had.
Then to add insult to injury, they elect to put this "newly found" money into the capital reserve fund, therefore setting the taxpayers up for another tax hike.
Please plan to attend these important meetings, and let's start getting this district back on track (excuse the pun).
"The media is currently blowing it way out of proportion. No need to panic. "
Why should we panic? MRSA is resistant to anti-biotics and can kill. As long as we have a new synthetic field we can all feel safe.
You're right. Of course. What was I thinking?!?!?! Be afraid, be very afraid. MRSA is coming, and we're all going to die...only those who live in the dreaded Oley Valley, of course! Is that better? More suitable to your tastes? I thought so!
By the way, life is fatal as well. I guess we should all crawl in a hole and die!
Ever talk to anyone that has MRSA? It's horrible, painful, unpredictable, and expensive to treat. You can spend months in the hospital and expect to take the misery home with you. No one will be glad to see you. Surgeons "cut out" the affected areas. This is nothing to take lightly.
Ever talk to anyone that has a negative outlook? It's horrible, painful, unpredictable, and expensive to treat. You can spend your lifetime expecting to take your misery home with you. No one will be glad to see you. Surgeons may try to "cut out" the affected areas, but undoubtedly they will not succeed. This is nothing to take lightly.
'...Ever talk to anyone that has MRSA?...'
I have. I volunteer at the reading hospital, and well over 25% of the elderly patients have MRSA, and it has been like that for at least the past 3+ years.
It is not nearly the big deal that the media and left wing wacko's make it out to be. The flu is just as deadly.
First Budget and Finance Committee meeting tonight, minus some key people -
the three candidates who are on the ballot.
LIGHTS - CAMERA - TAX INCREASE!
That' right folks, lights are coming to our new track and turf field - even though up until this point it has been quitely spoken about, no motion or vote was ever taken and it was not discussed in any detail.
Tonight they talked like it was a done deal.
Get your wallets out!
And let's not forget the new addition to the high school!
dear 'flu'
I never saw anyone with the flu have to get 'chunks' of flesh CUT OUT of them. You may need a check up yourself.
Post a Comment